The Problem with Reviewing Anime
Közzététel: 3 hónapja
Megtekintés 952 E
Get the best discount of the year on Raycons! Now through the end of November, go to buyraycon.com/gigguk to get 20% off your order!
Today I talk about the lost art of Anime reviews and why they are a none-factor in our community.
Edited by: Bakashift
BakaShift
Patreon: www.Patreon.com/Gigguk
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter: GiggukAZ
Like me on Facebook: GiggukAZ
Follow me on Instagram: giggukaz
HERO SPEEDY
11 órája
is full metal alchemist the same as full metal alchemist brotherhood? or are they completely different?
Sixth Volcano 988
4 napja
The only review that matters is the moist meter
Tustin Yang
4 napja
Facts
westenev
6 napja
I think MAL reviews have a lot of merit in this community. 10-9 = this anime is currently airing and people are ironically upvoting it. 8-7 = A good anime. 6-5 = trashy b-grade anime that niche audiences will enjoy. 4-0 = you will enjoy this show ironically while drinking with friends.
LooolxAnime
6 napja
NAA IMMA STILL REVIEW ANIME LOOL🔥😎
¿JATIN TOMAR?
6 napja
9:14 so you mean anime,manga,light novel,work of art,books and then all book of science and evry single data become main stream
Woopity Scoop
7 napja
I love that this is really only a new problem.
BazouK
8 napja
I believe I heard something linked to mozzarella somewhere in this video, right ?
Sprunk
8 napja
Gigguk: The problem with reviewing anime Also Gigguk: *reviews anime*
black the killer
9 napja
I heard the alucard theme
sersys1
11 napja
Looking for a good anime is like shoveling through dung to find a diamond. I leave the dirty work to the reviewer and skip right to the treasure.
TOA 12th
12 napja
This is why I don't watch adaptations. I watch original anime, and read manga and light novels.
Баунти Шмаунти
12 napja
Это обзор?))
Skankhunt42
12 napja
I watch GR's reviews after finishing shows, more as a discussion than anything
I Eat Kids
13 napja
I think anime reviews are less of a review and more of a reccomendation I found some great shows by looking at reviews
Maher Rahman
14 napja
Gigguk: " Ooga, ooga, ooga, booga " HUeye CC: " Ah yes, *MUSIC* " 😂😂😂
GLUTEUS MAXIMUS
16 napja
The boi is learning!!! I'm proud of him!!! HUeye should recommend this video to every toxic weeabo that likes to judge everything after a couple of episodes.
walter hank
16 napja
IGN = IGNORE THE IGNORANCE
Nerves
16 napja
oregairu was also another of those for me. s2 really made me fall in love with the characters and the story
Gublai Sensei
16 napja
MaNgA is BeTtEr ThAn ANimE
pls don't ban me again you libtards
17 napja
swear you go to any anime review on MAL and most of the bad reviews are all preliminary. I get you may not want to finish something you don't like but I just find something disingenuous about that and it probably impacts overall scores quite considerably.
DarkCobra88
18 napja
Just found this channel and I like its content and totally agree here. (also, Mami is the best girl, I know what I saw!). i like anime is accepted more now but it is also concerning the more mainstream it becomes the more its uniqueness could waver. On topic, I order forum discussions by the episode now days, reviews as you say dont hold the same weight as everyone moves on, I love discussing the show so episode discussions give the fun that reviews did and still let you keep up with everyone.
Siraj
18 napja
I like this guy, he knows what he's talking about (cause he has anime posters in his room)
Helmsguard
19 napja
Whats that anime at 8:50 ?
Comodo Gaming678
19 napja
I tried watching demon slayer but I couldn't complete it
frostyoakbite
19 napja
thank you gigguk echidna is best girl in re:zero no othe contestants
si2foo
21 napja
Review's have never mattered in any medium. A Review is a opinion by a person they are only helpful when you know what that person likes and dislikes. I also have no fucking idea what shit your saying about it being hard to find anime back in 2006 because it was easy as hell.
Gavilan Gordon-Chavez
21 napja
The bay area is calling, we want our "hella" back
Luke Lemke
22 napja
I love how insightful you are... about the anime industry. It's great.
Schippai
23 napja
All I don't understand is why no one is talking about "My Dress-up Girl", cause that show is wild.
PC Willis
23 napja
As an anime only. Shut up OR read the manga. Simple as that. No more wars.
PC Willis
23 napja
Seriously, you and LongBeachGriffy love Raycon earbuds.
Trex Enigma
23 napja
Considering what trash "journalists" and "professional reviewers" write on other mediums, I see this as a good thing! Unless you enjoy reading a review about how an anime like One-Piece apparently has too much water.
Airborne Z
24 napja
S2 part 2 rezero is just so bad
Just a turtle
21 napja
Season 2 part 2 of re:zero is just too good
Conrad McCracken
25 napja
The problem with anime reviews are opinions
TheEo300
25 napja
The Claymore-to-Haruhi transition at 8:11... how?
Eli Nugget
26 napja
Demon slayers is overated
Saturday Video Guild Productions
27 napja
Gigguk is 30! Wait shit. Im 24 now
Jordan williams
27 napja
Oh my gosh! That is Matt Lees!! I love that guy!!! 0:49
Gag1800
27 napja
Light novel anime drive me nuts, they get like one or two seasons, then never get any more episodes ever again and what was covered in those seasons barely scratches the surface of the source material's story, which in all likelihood is still ongoing anyway. But so many of them are really good that I can't help but watch, however I can't bring myself to read the LN because it's just not the same
MobiusBoi
27 napja
Im pretty sure ReZero will get a 3rd season, and its web novel (which is ahead of the light novel but the light novel adapts it) its novel is super good
Cromalin
28 napja
God, the hellsing ost was so good
That one kid
28 napja
7/10 too much water
sai bondada
28 napja
This video was released on my birthday
Samuel Raji
28 napja
It seems you are unfamiliar with the absolute wasteland that is non superhero comics. Search top comics of the year and it comes up with list from respected publications but every fucking list is different with no overlap. So you just need to wing it a lot of times you find gems but sometimes you waste your time because nobody knows if a comic is actually good. Atleast anime has community driven ratings even though they are not very consistent.
chanter panter
28 napja
I came when I saw Claymore being mentioned
republic gamer
29 napja
I remember you anime review videos, my very first video i watch on your channel was the school day one
Deep Fried Coal
Hónapja
season 4 AOT is even better in the first episodes they just commit verdun on a whole city
LowHP
Hónapja
6:15 I love peepee
why iloveit
Hónapja
oof first time i seen on your channel black lagoon
Sir Deadpoolio
Hónapja
U like Garabage?
Nguyên Minh Hồ
Hónapja
You know one exception? SAO. That shit ain't improving
Hell boy
Hónapja
it doesn't matter gigguk we love your videos
Lizby
Hónapja
Awesome video, holmes!
top10
Hónapja
9:07 what the fuclk is this fire song I need to know
Silvitair
Hónapja
ECHIDNA BEST GIRL LET'S GO. Ah i see you're a man of culture as well...
Gilgabro
Hónapja
Fucking plebs who don't read Magna have no right to critique my favorite anime. Reeeeeee!1!!
sleepysloth
Hónapja
Anime only reviews should be targeting anime onlies coz they serve no values to manga readers. So manga readers should have no business in having that debate. On the other hand, there are few good anime/manga critics just because of the age/quality of its target audience.
Takkun
Hónapja
anime zone coming back confirmed?
Zan
Hónapja
I agree with everything in this video. It's still so weird to think that anime can be watched by anyone and no one cares about opinions but it's still such a toxic community in so many places.
Ethameshep
Hónapja
So opinions are irrelevant and misinformed? I wish more people understood this.
AnimeAddict
Hónapja
Really gonna call out all of us who click on any video with a show we love in it just hoping to hear another validating opinion on it huh
Angel says Teri, I love you
Hónapja
Ok so bleach is a 9 out of ten . RIGHT
george vila
Hónapja
Re zero is pure shit
Just a turtle
Hónapja
@george vila see you’re just another one of those guy being weak does not = bad goku is op as hell but he’s a shitty character and I’m pretty sure he can beat you in a physical fight so don’t act like a big shot when you’re not because unlike you he actually want and have improve throughout the series
george vila
Hónapja
@Just a turtle so you dont get turned off how pathetic this mc is. He is weak and pathetic. All the trouble happened because he was chasing pussy that was out of his league. He is surrounded by girls who fight for and protect him... he gets emotional cries and complains wanting to protect something he cant. This emotional betamale mc is content staying weak and pathetic. With that power he could improve himself. Instead he dies and retires trying to find the path with better results. If I called the mc a betamale its because it's perfect description. Refute my points.
Just a turtle
Hónapja
@george vila I’m not into beta males and with that statement I know that I can take you for a joke sine you’re just another one of those people that throw out random accusations instead of using their brain hater
george vila
Hónapja
@Just a turtle if your into betamales losers
Just a turtle
Hónapja
Re zero is pure masterpiece
Yoko Spaghetti
Hónapja
Bad video. Just a ripoff of dunkey's game reviewer videos. 10/10. It has a little bit of something for everyone.
Jon-John Pinckney
Hónapja
I'm laughing at the Twitter people who thought AZ Garnt & Gigguk Garnt were two different people!
Golden910
Hónapja
I wish I found your channel years ago
Gabriel Fernandez
Hónapja
6:58 DitF ost 👀
Casually Spelic
Hónapja
I feel like anime is just a medium where shows can range from really clicking with someone to the complete opposite, and this completely changes from person to person. Ex: for some reason now people are excited about Bleach returning, I don't get it but I guess I'm just not the type to throth at the mouth for Shonen.
Matthew Telles
Hónapja
Raycon is such a shit product and you can get much better products for way less money.
Ghidorah
Hónapja
Genuinely couldn't get into ReZero, I forced myself to watch season 1 and at the end I just hated the experience, i could like season 2 better but idk... I don't really feel like watching more of it
Z
17 napja
Watch in 10 years when you became 20 years old.
VTAO
Hónapja
Manga master race rise up.
Edmund Chang
Hónapja
you should add the anime where you got the scenes from in the very corner of the screen. So if we find something that catches our eyes we can watch it :)
MISTER SIR
Hónapja
Anime reviewers: This is the TOP 10 list of animes you MUST WATCH! Me, having seen a 5 second clip of a cute anime girl in a meme somewhere: *"this is it, Chief!"*
༒Synranelt, Holy Archangel of Death༒
Hónapja
ngl, that is how all of us find new anime. Memes.
robert conlon
Hónapja
Sorry, I'm too monke brain and I speed ran this video by using the skip to the end shortcut. Sure, it cuts out most of the context, but I still had a good time. 6/2, would play again.
Jason
Hónapja
I watch discussions because the anime went over my head and I want to join the enjoyment of it
Classy
Hónapja
*video says 2011* Gigguk: over 13 years ago Me: W-what?
VASU HARDEO
Hónapja
that was awesome !
Mustafa Bilge
Hónapja
People decide what to watch on others opinions ? I used to search for female characters and watch it. Well I've taste now. I don't watch anime , i read manga.
Andres Valera
Hónapja
I wish all industries adapted this format, I don't care how ""objectively"" good a movie is if it's not in a genre / about something I like
RoboDrags
Hónapja
raycon sponsorship ruined the video.. 4/10
Dhananjay mohali
Hónapja
Things should be reviewed on the basis of what show shows us not comoare with other shows
Rustyhound
Hónapja
Anime watchers and manga readers. Name a more iconic rivalry
Rustyhound
Hónapja
7.8/10 -too much anime
Gleam Maikeru
Hónapja
7:05 song?
Anolyso
Hónapja
#w-watchSymphogear...plz ;___;
DJ_KOEN
Hónapja
I kind of wanted to post videos on HUeye as well at some point but i have lost faith in myself i think At least i can still enjoy gigguk videos And think to myself what i think about the subject
Not Player
Hónapja
season 4 is so good
Gloria Watkins
Hónapja
The lumpy watchmaker undoubtedly provide because record particularly melt given a thin whistle. worthless, warlike dolphin
Common Sense
Hónapja
Gigguk: I'm kinda Glad there is no sexualize critic 95% of Anime News Networks, MAL, Crunchyroll reviewers and Twitter: Guess Again, B!tch!
Mikle Allard
Hónapja
That "80% of anime remain unfinished" point is exactly why I seek out reviews. I don't want to be left disappointed by the lack of a proper ending.
Jason
Hónapja
Same. I also look for validation, like right now.
theonethatrise rising
Hónapja
But we all know the best. Is Jojo!!!
Jewel-Kun
Hónapja
I'm tired of the anime community. I just wanna disconnect from it and enjoy anime the way i'll enjoy it the way it is...
Javez cruper
Hónapja
Agreed
Burakovic
Hónapja
8:09 SAUCE MATERIAL ?!
Assassin Cel
Hónapja
Who needs a review when you watch everything that releases out
Shaz
Hónapja
I loved this video but i think the script was better. A solid 7/10!
Ty Barros
Hónapja
6 blagoalshofs out of a number of them.
Neltins
Hónapja
Nice, now review new attack on titan season
1Aquadon
Hónapja
Yeh...... But His Taste Is "SHIT"!!! Thanks, Gugguk! You Rock!!!
H Orsidus
Hónapja
It's so true people don't give a shit. I've watched stuff that I liked and people claimed was a boring anime whilst i've recommended some of the best anime on MAL and other sites to friends and they just rewatch SAO and I cry a little every time. But at the same time there are shows that aren't masterpieces or even that great that are my guilty pleasures. Sometimes regardless of how good a show is or the general consensus on the quality of it there will always be people who enjoy it and dont give a crap about and since a lot of anime fans like to pretend they're fucking connoisseurs and intentionally act overly critical or overly positive about a show they personally connected with their reviews are general garbage anyway.
Deofol
Hónapja
Well I'd have to say that I disagree with reviews not mattering. It's not that the vast amount of reviews help its more so that you follow certain reviewers because they have similar tastes. I don't like everything you recommend but you introduced to me a few shows including vinland saga which was awesome. So keep up the good work.